Not everyone will like the outcome, but it will be fair.
Bad choices may lead to the loss of something precious. If an offer seems too good to be true, it probably is. Don't take unnecessary risks if you can't afford to lose. It is not worth the risk.
If you give someone a fish, they can eat for a night. If you give them a fishing rod, they can eat every night. The same example is true when it comes to praise and feedback. You can give someone a temporary boost by offering praise, or you can help them to improve and grow by offering feedback. Feedback will last longer and have a far greater impact than mere praise.